As is her habit, the Beloved is listening to Jonathan Schwartz’s Christmas show on WNYC-FM, where his guests include Mandy Patinkin, Charles Osgood, Jay Leonhart, Steve LaSpina, Harry Allen, John Pizzarelli, Tony Monte, and Gene Bertoncini.  When the chatter comes to a graceful halt, Jonathan offers high-quality seasonal music, including tenor saxophonist Harry’s romp through “Santa Claus Is Coming to Town.” 

The Beloved, quite properly, was delighted with Harry’s performance.  But she asked me, “Do jazz musicians really enjoy playing such silly songs?” 

“Santa Claus Is Coming To Town” is well-established in the American cultural landscape, ubiquitous, even.  I used to roll my eyes whenever it was played.  However, when I found out that it had been composed by J. Fred Coots, composer of “You Go To My Head” and “For All We Know,” I was able to feel more kindly towards the song.  Somehow it appealed to me that Coots should have made a fortune on this musical shred — enabling him to live comfortably and write far better songs.   

I answered the Beloved’s question by invoking the Sage of Corsicana, Texas, Hot Lips Page, who, when asked a similar question, reputedly said, “The material is immaterial.”  And Django Reinhardt, who surely knew something about improvisation, asked for the simplest theme from “Tiger Rag” as material to improvise on at a jam session. 

Like alchemists, jazz musicians inhabit a miraculous universe, turning junk into gold, often enjoying the vapidity of a piece of music because its three-chord structure allows them to improvise freely while the F, G7, and C are endlessly returning.  Think of the twelve-bar blues as the perfect example.  The freedom to create as one wishes — what a blessing!

But back to seasonal matters.  Between now and Christmas, I am always tempted to equip myself with a pair of earplugs when I go out in public.  I would be thrilled to hear Bing’s “White Christmas” once a day, but “The Little Drummer Boy” performed with funk underpinnings raises my blood pressure alarmingly.  So I propose two aesthetic alternatives for the season.

mark-shane-santaOne is the best, most jubilant jazz Christmas CD I have ever heard: Mark Shane (and his X-mas All-Stars, including Jon-Erik Kellso) on the Nagel-Heyer label, WHAT WOULD SANTA SAY?  It’s a CD I enjoy all through the year.    

The other piece of music is accessible online, as I found to my delight.  It’s a 1944 record made for the Savoy label, featuring the delightfully accomplished pianist Johnny Guarneri and the irreplaceable bassist Slam Stewart.  A truly irrepressible pair! 

The song — apparently improvised impromptu in the studio — is called SANTA’S SECRET, a jolly evocation of Fats Waller, who had died less than a year before.  It answers the pressing question, “What makes Santa so jolly?”  Whether Johnny and Slam were Tall when they recorded this I leave to scholars more erudite than myself. 

If you visit (which bills itself as offering the worst Christmas songs ever recorded — a position I don’t hold) and search for “Guarneri,” all should be revealed.  The link is genuinely troublesome, but it is alive and worth pursuing.      

In this holiday season and beyond, I hope that you are as happy as Johnny and Slam seem to be on that record.  And that you get to display your very own alchemical wizardries, even if you don’t play an instrument.


  1. wise choice to place “reefers” in your tag list! You are now on an FBI list.

    “Those who sit and wait also serve”
    –Milton (either John or my Uncle Milton from Bayonne)

    Happy Solstice and rebirth of light!

  2. A mainstreamer’s all-time Xmas CD list:
    1 Harry Allen, Christmas in Swingtime
    2 Joe Augustine, Christmas Is
    3 Gerry Beaudoin, A Sentimental Christmas
    4 Blue Note, Yule Struttin’
    5 Bullseye, Season’s Greetings
    6 A Chiaroscuro Christmas
    7 Ella Fitzgerald, Ella Wishes You a Swinging Christmas
    8 Jim Galloway & Jay McShann, Jim & Jay’s Christmas
    9 Eddie Higgins Trio, Christmas Songs
    10 Eddie Higgins Trio & Scott Hamilton, Christmas Songs II
    11 Oliver Jones, Yuletide Swing
    12 Stacey Kent, The Christmas Song
    13 Diana Krall, Christmas Songs
    14 David Leonhardt Jazz Group, I’ll Be Home for Christmas
    15 Gap Mangione, Family Holidays
    16 Dave McKenna, Christmas Party
    16 Nagel Heyer Records, Christmas Jazz
    17 Nagel Heyer Records, Christmas Jazz, Vol 2
    18 Joe Pass, Christmas Guitar Dreams
    19 Oscar Peterson, An OP Christmas
    20 Marcus Roberts, A Prayer for Peace
    21 Sackville Recordings, The Sackville All Star Christmas Record (Hinton/Sutton/Johnson/Galloway)
    22 Anton Schwartz, Holiday Time
    23 Mark Shane’s Xmas All Stars, What Would Santa Claus Say
    24 Tall Jazz, Plays Winter Jazz (w/ Rebecca Kilgore)
    25 Trio West, Plays Holiday Songs
    26 Steve Tyrell, This Time of the Year
    27 Nancy Wilson, A NW Christmas
    All these sessions swing, & only 3 are marred by the inclusion of “Little Drummer Boy”.

  3. Sackville All Star Christmas Record has to be the BEST Christmas record, it swings all the way and Ralph Sutton is sublime.

  4. I listened to a bit of the music from the Charlie Brown xmas special (performed by the Vince Guaraldi trio) last night. It is still one of the few holiday albums I can stomach – partly for sentimental reasons (as I always watched that special while growing up), but also because Guaraldi and Co. really played well on the disc. “Christmas Time is Here” is an underrated holiday classic, and Guaraldi’s solo on O Tannenbaum really swings hard – further proof of Hot Lips Page’s dictum on material.

  5. No comment – just wishing you and the B. a happy and healthy New Year.

    Also wishing you good Shuzzit. (For the uninitiated, that’s an obscure Jewish holiday, one that should be celebrated year-round.)

    Your faithful correspondent and conaisisoeur,


  6. Thanx, Bob, for the support on the Sackville All Star Christmas Record. Last year I sent copies to 20 friends & fellow jazz fans, to great appreciation. This year, I bought the last 15 copies of Jim & Jay’s Christmas that John Norris at Sackville had in stock. I’m a little late getting them out, but recipients so far have been enthusiastic.

  7. I just want to add Dave Brubeck’s recording of “The Christmas Song” to John Herr’s list. I’m sure he’ll approve it !

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s