“MONSTROUS!” SHE SAYS

Lisa Ryan, who creates lovely impressionistic YouTube video-collages related to Bix Beiderbecke, sent along this quotation she found in a biography of Josephine Baker.  The speaker is dancer Isadora Duncan:

It seems to me monstrous that anyone should believe that the jazz rhythm expresses America. Jazz rhythm expresses the primitive savage.

I wonder what “jazz rhythm” she had heard in her days and nights in the United States, Paris, and Moscow.  Had she been terrortized by the primitive passions of Bechet, Miley, or Oliver, I would understand.  But I wonder if the music that so upset her was no more than a tea-dance band (violin, saxophone, piano, drums) one-stepping through STUMBLING.  Or did she get upset when someone read Vachel Lindsay’s THE CONGO aloud? 

Poor Miss Duncan: she didn’t go to the right places or hear the right recordings.  Would James P. Johnson’s SNOWY MORNING BLUES have struck her as “monstrous,” or the dancing of Bill Robinson?  Was her terror the fear of all things African-American?  I hope not. 

I must be off, to see David Ostwald and the Louis Armstrong Centennial Band devote themselves to the music of that “savage” Mr. Armstrong.  It will amuse me to envision Miss Duncan, clapping her hands over her ears and fleeing as the band begins its Wednesday night ritual of WHEN IT’S SLEEPY TIME DOWN SOUTH.  Oh, what Isadora missed . . . !

5 responses to ““MONSTROUS!” SHE SAYS

  1. John P. Cooper

    She doesn’t seem to be expressing fear or terror. She merely states the then commonly held theory of Jazz and jungle rhythm.

    Maybe she got all tangled up.

  2. I’ll leave aside any possible comment on your final jest . . but look up “monstrous” in your handy dictionary sometime, John! I could be ascribing more paranoia to Miss Duncan than she actually felt, but her language is very strong. Ne c’est pas?

  3. John P. Cooper

    You may well be right. These high toned art folks often engage in dramatic prose when expressing themselves. It’s just their way.

  4. I have it on good authority that Isadora’s afterlife preoccupations has her jealously guarding original Okeh Hot Fives and Sevens lest The Diety steal them away.

  5. Pingback: “MONSTROUS!” SHE SAYS

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s