The global attic / museum / antique shop known as eBay never fails to surprise.  Here’s something recently posted — the sheet music for a James P. Johnson / Andy Razaf song, HAVIN’ A BALL.  I don’t think it enjoyed wide currency, and I suspect it was another version of SPREADIN’ RHYTHM AROUND and THE JOINT IS JUMPIN’ — that is, once the music is hot, everyone is happy.  Valid enough.

James P. recorded it for Columbia in 1939 — under the aegis of John Hammond — with a band including Henry “Red” Allen, Gene Sedric, J. C. Higginbotham, and Sidney Catlett — but the sides weren’t issued at the time and they only emerged on a 1962 compilation of James P.’s Columbia recordings.

Sometimes the business of music is as intriguing as the music itself.  Too much has been made of Goodman as Caucasian exploiter, and in 1937 he hardly needed to extort money from James P., Razaf, or Joe Davis to have his picture on the cover — a sure guarantee of increased sales.  And he isn’t a “co-composer” here, which suggests that the Goodman band actually played this song.  Goodman expert/ discographer David Jessup says that no broadcast performances of it exist to his knowledge.  Of course, the band might have played it at a dance that wasn’t documented or for a broadcast that wasn’t notated by Bob Inman or captured by an enthusiast with a disc recorder.

But I wonder how this partnership came to be.  Did one of the composers or publisher Davis “reach out” (as they used to say on television police shows) to a Goodman arranger and work out a mutually advantageous arrangement: a good tune for a swing band, let’s get it some airplay?  Youth wants to know.

Alas, I can’t provide an audio track.  You’ll have to find a copy of the Columbia lp FATHER OF THE STRIDE PIANO or the Classics CD on which it appears: I recall a Meritt Record Society vinyl issue had several alternate takes.

In its heyday, the tune was recorded by Fats Waller, Billy Kyle, George Zack, Max Kaminsky . . . and there is presumably a 1958 Goodman version, which suggests that an actual arrangement was created.  But when?  The only contemporary version I know is found on the Arbors CD by the International Hot Jazz Quartet — Duke Heitger, Engelbert Wroebel, Paolo Alderighi, Oliver Mewes.

Have yourself a ball!

May your happiness increase.

8 responses to ““HAVIN’ A BALL” with JAMES P. JOHNSON, ANDY RAZAF, and . . . BENNY GOODMAN (1937)

  1. The ’58 recording I believe you are referring to is from a quintet session with Previn, Kessel, Vinnegar, and Capp, so no dating or earlier performance clues from that “arrangement.”

  2. Ah! I wasn’t even sure if was the James P. tune or a themeless romp on something . . . . one guesses when one is away from one’s sources . . . thanks, fellow!

  3. Here’s Billy Kyle’s version – I just uploaded it to youtube.


  4. “Too much has been made of Goodman as Caucasian exploiter”

    Ya – and I think for the most part those days have passed save for the ill-informed.

    I realized some time ago that the same like-minded people who would complain about ‘Goodman stealing Black people’s music’ would have been the same people to complain about ‘Goodman ignoring Black people’s music’ had he chosen not to play any.

  5. The titles ” Havin’ a Ball ” , and ” Swingin’ at the Lido ” are permuted on the LP, Father of the Stride Piano. ” Swingin’ at the Lido ” was co composed with Willie ” the Lion ” Smith, and shares a theme with ” Gut Stomp ” ( easily confirmed when listening to the Blue Note solo ) which is also credited to both men. In going through James P’s papers, I found a composition which Jimmy dedicated to Benny Goodman. I cannot remember the title. I suspect that Scott Brown will be discussing this in his upcoming 2nd edition of the James P. bio. I am inferring that James . P and Benny got together through the auspices of John Hammond, Benny’s father in law.

  6. Havin a Ball ( James P. Johnson / Andy Razaf ) from Policy Kings https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UyGAQkMQxH0

  7. This is a correctly designated recording of ” Havin’ a Ball “, by James P. Johnson and His Orchestra from 1939.

  8. Gut Stomp ( James P. Johnson and Willie ” The Lion Smith ) piano solo by James P. Johnson from Dec 1943, originally issued on Blue Note 24. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ms7HxZQixZg

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s