I was originally going to title this post HIDE THE CHILDREN but then it occurred to me that my caution was excessive.  No actual obscenities are uttered on these sides and the children of 2015 often know and use casually what 1936 listeners would have called “bad words.”

But these records were startling discoveries to me, and they swung — with a cast of characters not renowned in jazz lore.  The records also weren’t under-the-counter “party records,” but issued in 1936 on a major label (Decca’s race series, but note the absence of “Sepia Series” on the label).


and the reverse, more familiar, praise of the humble tuber on the commodities market:


Happily, I found the personnel as reported in Storyville 144, courtesy of the National Jazz Archive (UK) here —

STELLA JOHNSON Vocal, acc, by Dorothy Scott’s Rhythm Boys: Randolph Scott or Jimmy Strange, t; Bob Fagin, as; Dorothy Scott or Henry Gordon, p; Bob Tinsley, g, *Bassie* sb; Pete Peterson, d.  Chicago, Thursday, 10 Sept.1936:

90868-A Don’€™t Come Over De 7217

90869-A Hot Nuts Swing De 7217.

I offer no moral here, except to point out how good the band sounds, how adept the unheralded Bob Fagin is in the pre-Bird style, how effective the overall swing sounds.

On DON’T COME OVER, the device of creating a rhyme where the second rhyming word, unspoken, is clearly vulgar, must go back several centuries in vernacular folk music.  It is particularly intriguing because it requires listeners to reach into their personal word-hoards and come up, perhaps involuntarily, with the naughty word, the obscene punchline to the joke.  We become participants in the naughty playlet.  Consider that.

May your happiness increase!

5 responses to “NAUGHTY, NAUGHTY (1936)


    I don’t know if this qualifies, but long ago Clint Baker hipped me to a recording called Two Times A Night, which supposedly was a song about a radio show which aired twice each night but the song exploits the double entendre. It’s also a cute song!

    Best Becky

    Sent from my iPhone


  2. Very interesting Michael. One worth looking up is ” Oh That Nasty Man” by Tiny Mayberry in 1938 with band including Charlie Shavers,Buster Bailey,Sam Price,Sid Catlett. The song is clearly the inspiration for the 1950s Doris Day hit ” A guy is a guy” ( amended lyrics by Oscar Brand ). A song about a stalker! Not very PC these days. Track is available on RST CD compilation “Jazzin’ the blues “

  3. I will give it a spin, for — remarkably as these things go — I not only have that CD but know where it is! (Any relation to Alice Faye’s OH, YOU NASTY MAN?)

  4. It’s a wonderful record — done by a singer whose name eludes me, with a small group from the 1932 Bennie Moten band of sacred memory: front line is Lips Page and Eddie Barefield, so you know it’s swinging. A long-time favorite.

  5. thank you! Also for the comment section. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s