Imagine a landscape without parkways and freeways, big-box stores, chain restaurants, and nail salons. Imagine being able to see the horizon and the stars. That America may be gone for good, swallowed up by the convenience of being able to drive to one shopping mall after another with jewelry stores and faux-ethnic eateries all in a row.
But the soundtrack of adventure, freedom, and “fifty miles of elbow room” flourished in the Thirties and Forties, on records, radio and television, and the movies. That music is still gratifying, speaking to longings for space, clear skies, fresh air, snow, and spring blossoms. Think of RIDING DOWN THE CANYON, TAKE ME BACK TO MY BOOTS AND SADDLE, THE LAST ROUNDUP, SAN ANTONIO ROSE, even HAPPY TRAILS TO YOU. Those songs enchanted listeners then and they can continue to do so with visions of what once was and might still exist somewhere.
Also the lure of getting away — where? Who cares. Away is its own justification. Even for those who have only ridden the Fiberglass horsie that requires quarters to safely simulate a ride.
And, in case you are wondering what all this apparent nostalgia for all things Western has to do with jazz, you can visit Art Tatum playing BOOTS AND SADDLE, Conne Boswell singing HOME ON THE RANGE, Red Allen and Al Bowlly enjoying ROLL ALONG, PRAIRIE MOON, Herb Jeffries with the Ellington band telling us about THE CALL OF THE CANYON.
But this post isn’t about nostalgia and venerable recordings. Hilary Gardner, singer and scholar, has been exploring the songs of the wide open spaces — specifically, “trail songs,” for a few years now, and I am here to report rewarding developments in 2024, with riding lessons not needed.
Hilary has been one of my favorite singers for the decade-plus that I’ve known her. She’s heartfelt without being self-dramatizing. She swings, but she is not someone who puts a song through the food processor to mince everything into a rhythmic pulp. She’s candid and full of feeling, but she’s also a New Yorker, so she has an ironic eyebrow at the ready for excess sentimentality. She can be very funny, essential to a performance of I’M AN OLD COWHAND. And, if you’ve never heard her, I will say the obvious: she has a beautiful voice, splendid diction, and she is an egalitarian on the bandstand: all rare and commendable virtues. And she only sings songs she has an emotional connection to, so she is never ever “phoning it in.”
During the pandemic, Hilary began to explore songs that self-defined “cabaret singers” scorned in favor of obscure Ann Ronell and Johnny Mercer tunes. (And she also had to deal with tyrannical audience members who wanted her to stay in the corral they had marked off for her.) She and a fine group had their debut at Bar 55, which I couldn’t get to, and then a gig at Mezzrow in 2022, which I wrote about here.
But now it’s 2024, and I have more good news to report.
For one, Hilary and friends will be appearing at Mezzrow (163 West Tenth Street, Greenwich Village, New York) this Sunday night, at 7:30 and 9. Her friends are Justin Poindexter, guitar and voice, Noah Garabedian, double bass; Aaron Thurston, drums, and special guest Sasha Papernik, accordion and voice. You can buy tickets here or visit the free livestream if West Tenth Street is too far away.
And we all need something to make the long ride home easier, so I report with pleasure that Hilary’s new CD: ON THE TRAIL WITH THE LONESOME PINES, is coming out in March. To learn more about it (and perhaps to help it buy a better saddle) visit here.
Attentive readers will notice that the two entries above come from Hilary’s blog, which is a pleasure in itself. She’s a subtle unfussy writer, even if The New Yorker hasn’t yet turned its august head in her direction.
And as for you. You already know everything there is to know about I LOVE BEING HERE WITH YOU and MY FUNNY VALENTINE. There is life beyond the Great American Songbook. So ride along with Hilary and the Lonesome Pines, beyond the strip mall and the Cross Bronx Expressway. Old Paint will thank you.
May your happiness increase!